Table Variable vs Temporary Table in SQL Server – Which One Should You Use?

When working with SQL Server, developers often need to store temporary data for intermediate calculations. SQL Server provides two primary methods to handle this:

• Table Variables (@table_variable)
• Temporary Tables (#temp_table)

While both serve similar purposes, they differ significantly in performance, scope, and use cases. This article explores their differences with execution plans and real-world examples.

---

1. What is a Table Variable?

A Table Variable is a variable that holds data in a table structure but with limited scope and functionality. It is stored primarily in memory, though it can spill to disk when necessary.

Declaration and Usage

DECLARE @EmployeeTable TABLE (

    ID INT PRIMARY KEY,

    Name VARCHAR(100),

    Salary DECIMAL(10,2)

);

 

INSERT INTO @EmployeeTable (ID, Name, Salary)

VALUES (1, 'John Doe', 5000), (2, 'Jane Smith', 6000);

 

SELECT * FROM @EmployeeTable;

Key Characteristics

• Scoped to the batch or procedure where it is declared.
• No statistics are maintained, leading to poor execution plan optimization.
• Cannot be altered after declaration.
• Limited indexing capabilities (only PRIMARY KEY and UNIQUE constraints are allowed).
• Does not participate in transactions (rollback has no effect).

---

2. What is a Temporary Table?

A Temporary Table is a table that exists in the tempdb database and provides better performance for larger datasets due to indexing and statistics support.

Declaration and Usage

CREATE TABLE #EmployeeTemp (

    ID INT PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED,

    Name VARCHAR(100),

    Salary DECIMAL(10,2)

);

 

INSERT INTO #EmployeeTemp (ID, Name, Salary)

VALUES (1, 'John Doe', 5000), (2, 'Jane Smith', 6000);

 

SELECT * FROM #EmployeeTemp;

Key Characteristics

• Stored in tempdb and supports transactions.
• Supports full indexing, including Clustered and Non-Clustered Indexes.
• Statistics are generated, improving query performance.
• Can be altered (ALTER TABLE) after creation.
• Scope lasts until the session ends or explicitly dropped.

---

3. Key Differences Between Table Variables and Temporary Tables

Feature	Table Variable (@table_variable)	Temporary Table (#temp_table)
Scope	Limited to the batch/procedure.	Exists in tempdb until explicitly dropped or session ends.
Transaction Logging	Minimal logging, does not support rollback.	Fully logged and supports rollback.
Indexing	Only PRIMARY KEY and UNIQUE constraints.	Supports full Clustered and Non-Clustered Indexes.
Statistics	❌ No statistics, optimizer assumes 1 row.	✅ Maintains statistics, improving performance.
Recompilation	Does not cause stored procedure recompilation.	May cause recompilation.
Performance	Faster for small datasets (stored in memory).	More efficient for larger datasets (stored in tempdb).
Supports ALTER?	❌ No ALTER TABLE support.	✅ Can use ALTER TABLE to modify structure.

---

4. Execution Plan Comparison

Scenario:

We insert 10,000 records into both a Table Variable and a Temporary Table, then perform a JOIN operation and analyze the execution plan.

Using Table Variable

DECLARE @EmployeeTable TABLE (

    ID INT PRIMARY KEY,

    Name VARCHAR(100),

    Salary DECIMAL(10,2)

);

 

INSERT INTO @EmployeeTable

SELECT TOP 10000 ROW_NUMBER() OVER (ORDER BY (SELECT NULL)),

       'Employee ' + CAST(ROW_NUMBER() OVER (ORDER BY (SELECT NULL)) AS VARCHAR(10)),

       5000

FROM master.dbo.spt_values;

 

SELECT * FROM @EmployeeTable;

Execution Plan Analysis:

• No statistics are created, so SQL Server assumes 1 row exists.
• Uses Nested Loops Join, which is inefficient for large datasets.
• No parallelism.

---

Using Temporary Table

CREATE TABLE #EmployeeTemp (

    ID INT PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED,

    Name VARCHAR(100),

    Salary DECIMAL(10,2)

);

 

INSERT INTO #EmployeeTemp

SELECT TOP 10000 ROW_NUMBER() OVER (ORDER BY (SELECT NULL)),

       'Employee ' + CAST(ROW_NUMBER() OVER (ORDER BY (SELECT NULL)) AS VARCHAR(10)),

       5000

FROM master.dbo.spt_values;

 

SELECT * FROM #EmployeeTemp;

Execution Plan Analysis:

• Statistics are generated, so SQL Server correctly estimates 10,000 rows.
• Uses Hash Join / Merge Join, which is more efficient.
• Can leverage parallelism, improving performance.

---

5. When to Use Table Variables vs Temporary Tables

Scenario	Best Choice
Small datasets (<1,000 rows)	Table Variable (@table_variable)
Need rollback in a transaction	Temporary Table (#temp_table)
Need indexing beyond PRIMARY KEY	Temporary Table (#temp_table)
Need to modify table structure dynamically	Temporary Table (#temp_table)
Inside a stored procedure (avoiding recompilation)	Table Variable (@table_variable)

---

 

Conclusion

• Use Table Variables when working with small datasets and avoiding recompilation.
• Use Temporary Tables when working with large datasets, transactions, or complex indexing.

Understanding these differences will help optimize SQL Server performance and ensure efficient query execution. 🚀